![nicholas shuttie 58 nicholas shuttie 58](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/4d/85/ac/4d85ac587da4c487d67ccc97e886da17.jpg)
It didn't mean anything to him that he had done this to his friend." "Nicky Sutton said something like, 'What? We've got a deal.' In that moment, he acted like he could have been eating a sandwich. They convicted Sutton of first-degree murder for his grandmother's killing, and he was sentenced to life in prison. "He went through quite a story, which did not turn out to be true at all," Coffey said. Then, Sutton said, he wrapped up the bodies of Almon and his grandmother and, after saying a quick prayer, threw them both in the Nolichucky River. Suddenly, Almon struck him from behind and began tearing at his face before Sutton managed to grab the man's gun and fatally shoot him. 22 to discover his grandmother lying bloodied on the living room floor. In Sutton's telling, he returned home Dec. But Large disappeared with the money, he said, and Almon soon began demanding payment from Sutton. She also might have found out he had already killed John Large, his friend from high school who had been missing for four months, and Charles Almon, a bankrupt contractor whose gold Jaguar had turned up abandoned at a Newport hotel.ĭuring his murder trial, Sutton took the stand and stunned the jury when he claimed he and Large, 19, had pooled their cash with Almon, 46, in a bid to buy $75,000 worth of cocaine. The retired schoolteacher might have made the mistake of telling her grandson "no" when he asked for money.
![nicholas shuttie 58 nicholas shuttie 58](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FPwMmTHWYAMgUCQ.jpg)
Opinion: Death row inmate Nick Sutton saved my life Gov. 29, an autopsy found she had drowned in the river some 7 miles from her home. Investigators ultimately concluded the teen knocked his 58-year-old grandmother unconscious with a stick of firewood, wrapped her in a blanket and trash bags, chained her to a cinder block and threw her alive from Hale's Bridge into the Nolichucky River.Īfter searchers pulled her body from the icy waters Dec. Shifting storiesįacing questions from detectives who found blood stains in the carpet at his grandmother's house, Nicky Sutton first told one tale, then another. They reported her missing after she didn't show up Christmas Day. Neither story sounded like Dorothy Sutton, and her two daughters started to suspect their nephew. He insisted she would make the drive from Morristown to Knoxville after dark before claiming she had left the house on a date and never returned. The 18-year-old came with scratches on his face and an armful of presents she had wrapped. In 1979, Sutton showed up to his family's annual Christmas Eve dinner without his grandmother.